Chapter 1: The Reality of People-Pleasing

In my path of personal growth, I've encountered several significant revelations, one of which was particularly striking: my inclination to please others stemmed from selfish motivations rather than the noble intentions I once believed. My efforts to appease others weren’t genuinely about helping them; instead, they served to alleviate my own discomfort. Faced with the possibility of disagreement, I often defaulted to expressing opinions I thought others would prefer to hear. This allowed me to sidestep conflict while feeling a sense of relief.

It’s a tough reality to confront, but it’s nonetheless true. People-pleasing acts as an anxiety management tool, primarily aimed at fulfilling our desire for comfort rather than genuinely making others happy.

The Fear of Disruption

Challenging the established order was never my intention. I avoided saying or doing anything that might invite judgment from others. Instead, I became a chameleon, adapting myself to please those around me. Reflecting on this behavior, it becomes clear that people-pleasing is fundamentally manipulative; it operates on the idea that we can alter others' perceptions of us through our actions. This tendency is not only manipulative but also deceptive.

Authenticity fosters human connection, and trust is the foundation of friendships. My closest companions are those I can rely on for honesty, regardless of whether the feedback is positive or negative. They expect the same from me. However, navigating this landscape is no easy feat. This discussion isn't intended to criticize those who people-please; I still struggle with it myself. Rather, it aims to illuminate the dysfunctional nature of this behavior while acknowledging the genuine neurological factors that contribute to it—otherwise, we wouldn’t engage in it.

I recall a friend confiding in me about his relationship troubles. Although I listened carefully, I recognized the ways he contributed to the issues at hand. When asked for my thoughts, I could only echo his sentiments instead of sharing my own. It was painful to realize I couldn’t fully support him in that moment, but the anxiety I experienced deprived me of the authenticity needed to do so. This is the reality we face, yet it’s a reality we must learn to manage. Both ourselves and those around us deserve our complete and authentic selves.

The Neuroscience Behind People-Pleasing

Research indicates that the struggle to express disagreement is partially rooted in the pre-frontal medial cortex (pFMC) of our brains, among other areas. It's important to note that increased activity in a specific brain region correlates with certain behaviors. For instance, when fear arises, activity in the amygdala increases, confirming its role in our experience of fear.

Studies reveal that disagreement is associated with heightened activity in the pFMC. Why does this matter? This region is linked to cognitive dissonance, a critical mental state that occurs when our beliefs clash with our actions. It’s that uncomfortable tension when we want to express ourselves, but an internal voice warns us against it. For a people-pleaser asked for their opinion, this manifests as the choice between speaking the truth and risking conflict or telling a falsehood to avoid it.

Humans are inherently inclined to evade stress, opting for simpler paths rather than those that induce anxiety. You may wonder why a people-pleaser wouldn’t just speak their truth to alleviate the dissonance between their beliefs and their lies. The answer lies in the added stress that honesty can provoke. It’s often easier to agree with others than to risk confrontation, inadvertently perpetuating the cycle of stress.

Various factors may influence our tendency to shy away from the truth: societal norms may suggest that women should remain silent on specific topics; intimidation by authority figures like bosses may stifle expression; social anxiety or low self-esteem can further inhibit our willingness to be heard. These elements, among many others, lead us to deceive ourselves to avoid increased stress.

Additionally, ingrained habits can ease mental strain. If you’re accustomed to remaining silent, attempting to speak up can trigger more anxiety. This reality compounds the societal and interpersonal pressures swirling in your mind as you contemplate your choices. Consequently, resisting the urge to please others becomes a formidable challenge.

Finding a Path Forward

The solution lies in addressing the external and internal pressures that inhibit our ability to voice our opinions. By doing so, we reduce the cognitive dissonance we experience, making it easier to speak up. Let’s explore some of these pressures.

#### Low Self-Worth

For many people-pleasers, low self-esteem is a common underlying issue. Simply put, if you had a more robust sense of self, you wouldn't be as concerned about the opinions of others. You would engage in healthy disagreements without fear of negative repercussions on your self-image. Relying on others to validate our worth is a hallmark of people-pleasing. Improving self-esteem involves practicing self-care, surrounding yourself with supportive individuals, making healthier choices, and exploring the roots of your low self-worth. By enhancing self-esteem, we can lower the stress associated with decision-making, enabling us to express ourselves honestly without fear of backlash.

#### The Role of Practice

The pFMC is also involved in reinforcement learning, which helps establish habits based on our experiences. If you’ve had negative experiences when attempting to assert yourself, this area of the brain retains those memories, discouraging future attempts. Conversely, positive experiences reinforce the behavior. Its heightened activity during decision-making may stem from a lack of practice in speaking up combined with past negative encounters—perhaps from childhood.

As previously mentioned, the less you engage in a particular behavior, the more anxiety you’ll feel when you finally attempt it. This is why personal development can be challenging; it often requires navigating discomfort while trying to adopt new habits. Consistent practice in expressing your thoughts will help rewire your brain to recognize that nothing catastrophic will occur. Ironically, it’s not speaking up that harms us; rather, it’s the absence of authenticity that leads to missed opportunities, damaged relationships, and a sense of weakness. All these outweigh the potential for conflict, yet our minds are conditioned to view them differently.

#### Addressing Anxiety

Anxiety intertwines with this entire process, as it generates stress. While the previous strategies will indirectly address anxiety by boosting your confidence, it’s also essential to confront it directly. One effective approach is learning to observe your thoughts. Though it may sound cliché, this practice is grounded in reality and effectiveness. For those grappling with anxiety, I recommend meditation to enhance your capacity for mindfulness and develop self-regulation skills that are beneficial during stressful times. The Headspace app is a great place to begin.

Research consistently shows that meditation and mindfulness practices reduce activation in the amygdala, which, in turn, diminishes stress and fear responses. This means that during moments of cognitive dissonance and decision-making, you’ll experience less anxiety, allowing you to speak your truth with reduced fear of conflict. Addressing anxiety is a vital step for anyone struggling with people-pleasing tendencies.

Conclusion

Numerous other factors may influence our inclination to please others, but today, I’ve focused on a few key areas. The beauty of overcoming people-pleasing lies in the fact that addressing one aspect can positively affect others. The central theme here is stress: the more stress you feel when asked for your opinion or to engage in a task, the more likely you are to acquiesce, seeking relief from cognitive dissonance.

By tackling one area, you can lower overall stress and make progress in others. Instead of viewing this as an overwhelming challenge, approach it as a series of manageable tasks that contribute to a larger objective. Personal development is a journey that requires time and patience, but with consistency and self-compassion, you can succeed.

Thank you for taking the time to read this article. I truly appreciate your support! If you found value in this piece, please give it a few claps and follow Above The Middle for more insights. If you're interested in further reading, here are some related articles you might enjoy.

Explore the nuances of people-pleasing and its roots in selfishness in this insightful video.

Join a conversation about the impact of people-pleasing behavior and how it can be a reflection of deeper issues.