Choosing Between Qlik and Tableau: A Comprehensive Analysis
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction to Business Intelligence Tools
In today's data-driven environment, organizations are empowering their teams with Self-Service Business Intelligence (BI) tools. Among the most popular options are Qlik and Tableau. This analysis will explore the functionalities and advantages of both tools.
Photo by Maxime Gilbert on Unsplash
Section 1.1: Overview of Qlik
Qlik Sense is available as either a cloud-based or on-premise self-service BI solution. Beyond standard dashboarding and reporting features, it also incorporates Machine Learning capabilities and allows for server-side extensions to execute Python functions.
Most Notable Advantages:
- Compatible with both cloud and on-premise setups.
- Includes statistical and machine learning functionalities.
Qlik UI — Source: prisma-informatik
Section 1.2: Exploring Tableau
Tableau, owned by Salesforce, is also available in both on-premise and cloud formats. The platform offers tailored solutions for various industries, such as banking, healthcare, and manufacturing. It serves multiple business units including finance, HR, IT, marketing, and sales.
Example of the Tableau UI — Source: Tableau
Chapter 2: Comparing Qlik and Tableau
Both Qlik and Tableau share a similar set of features. Each tool provides ETL/ELT capabilities to extract, transform, and load data from various sources, supporting a multitude of connectors for data preparation. In addition to dashboarding, both platforms include statistical and machine learning tools. Like Qlik, Tableau can integrate Python scripts, requiring a connection to a TabPy server.
The capabilities of both solutions are extensive, particularly when compared to simpler tools like Google Looker Studio, which has more basic functionalities.
This video explores the differences between Qlik and Tableau, focusing on their unique features and user experiences.
In this video, a detailed comparison of Tableau and Qlik Sense is presented from a developer's perspective, highlighting their advantages.
Section 2.1: Market Position
According to Gartner's analysis, both Qlik and Tableau are recognized as leading solutions, alongside Microsoft Power BI. This indicates that the choice between the two often comes down to personal preference and pricing models rather than significant differences in functionality.
Gartner Magic Quadrant for Analytics and BI Platforms 2022 — Source: Qlik
Sources and Further Readings
- Qlik Community, "Add Python Script to Qlik Sense" (2020)
- prisma-informatik, "Qlik Sense May 2021 — What’s New?" (2021)
- Wikipedia, "Tableau Software" (2022)
- Tableau, "Our Products" (2022)
- Qlik, "Gartner Magic Quadrant for Analytics and BI Platforms 2022"