Will Web Components Outperform iFrames in the Future?
Written on
Understanding the Evolution of Web Technologies
In previous discussions, I've delved into how to implement web components using Angular Elements. However, the conversation surrounding web components extends far beyond mere implementation. They offer a standardized approach to sharing components and functionalities across various web platforms. In our last piece, we crafted a contact form utilizing Angular Elements, highlighting their seamless integration into websites. This functionality mirrors what iFrames have traditionally provided. In this article, we will explore the distinctions between these two technologies, their similarities, and what the future may hold for both.
What Exactly is an iFrame?
Simply put, an iFrame is an HTML document embedded within another HTML document. You may have encountered various forms of iFrames, often without realizing it. Introduced by Microsoft in the late 90s, iFrames became the go-to solution for embedding one site into another for many years. Even today, countless websites continue to rely on them, primarily due to the lack of a superior alternative that offers cross-platform compatibility.
At its essence, an iFrame does not genuinely embed anything into a website; rather, it serves as a viewing window to another site. This approach comes with several challenges:
- Aesthetic Discrepancies: iFrames often disrupt the visual flow of a website. When linking two sites with vastly different styles, the iFrame can appear out of place. Additionally, they are fixed in size, making it challenging to position them in a way that looks natural.
- Performance Drawbacks: Loading an iFrame means fetching all the content from the embedded site. If the external site is poorly optimized, it can negatively impact your site’s performance. Unlike script tags, iFrames cannot be deferred, leading to potential delays in loading.
- Security Concerns: Embedding any site as an iFrame introduces security vulnerabilities. If the site being embedded has security flaws, your site could be compromised as well.
What are Web Components?
Web components allow for the creation of custom components that can be utilized universally. Instead of relying on the iFrame tag, web components enable developers to create their own unique HTML tags. Moreover, web components can be exported as NPM packages if desired.
While at a glance, iFrames and web components may seem similar, they are fundamentally different. An iFrame acts as a portal to another website, whereas a web component is an individual unit that can be utilized by users. Importantly, not everything can be transformed into a web component. They adhere to modern web standards and utilize a set of APIs to embed components into websites through HTML tags.
Web components effectively address the challenges associated with iFrames. Let’s break this down:
- Visual Integration: Web components can be designed to blend harmoniously with the host website. Being small, they can adopt styles from the parent site while retaining their own distinct styling. For instance, if the stylesheet does not specify a font, the web component will inherit the parent site’s font, creating a smooth user experience.
- Improved Performance: Web components are imported via script tags, which can be deferred. This means the component loads after the main site, ensuring that it doesn’t hinder initial rendering. The overall package sizes are generally smaller since only one site is being loaded at a time.
- Enhanced Security: Unlike iFrames, web components cannot simply be created from any website. Using web components resembles installing an NPM package, allowing for better security measures. While security is not flawless, it is significantly more robust than that associated with iFrames. Developers can implement API keys for added protection, which, though requiring additional effort, is worthwhile.
For those interested in crafting a web component, I have a dedicated article on that topic: Using Web Components in Angular.
The Future of Web Components and iFrames
The pivotal question remains: will web components render iFrames obsolete? Ideally, I would love to see that happen! I envision a promising future for web components, one that diminishes the reliance on iFrames. They can accomplish nearly everything iFrames do, but with greater efficiency and security. iFrames primarily offer straightforward and quick website embedding, a feature I believe is becoming increasingly outdated. In today’s context, iFrames represent security risks and performance issues.
Unfortunately, I don’t foresee iFrames disappearing anytime soon. The adoption of new technologies, even ones that aren’t entirely novel, requires time. Until web components gain broader acceptance, iFrames may continue to persist in the web development landscape.
I invite you to share your thoughts in the comments; I’m eager to hear your perspectives on the comparison between web components and iFrames.
If you found this article insightful, feel free to visit my website for this and more articles!
Chapter 1: Understanding iFrames and Web Components
In this chapter, we explore the foundational concepts of iFrames and web components, examining their core functionalities and historical significance.
Section 1.1: The Legacy of iFrames
iFrames have been integral to web development for decades, serving as a means to embed content. However, their limitations have led to the exploration of better alternatives.
The first video provides insights into the differences between web components and iFrames, highlighting the key distinctions that developers should be aware of.
Section 1.2: The Rise of Web Components
Web components have emerged as a modern solution to many of the problems associated with iFrames. Their ability to create reusable components marks a significant advancement in web technology.
The second video offers a concise overview of web components, showcasing how they can be effectively implemented in just 25 minutes.