Mastering the Two Envelopes Problem: A Winning Strategy
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding the Two Envelopes Paradox
The Two Envelopes Problem is a fascinating probability puzzle that has captured the attention of many. In this variation, you find yourself on a game show where the host presents two envelopes. Your task is to select one envelope and keep whatever amount it contains. The host provides crucial information:
- Each envelope holds a positive sum of money.
- One envelope contains exactly double the amount of the other.
After selecting an envelope and revealing its contents, the host prompts you to decide whether to switch to the other envelope. Is it advantageous to do so?
Section 1.1: The Dilemma of Switching
Let’s denote the amount in the envelope you opened as E?. The alternative envelope can either contain 2 * E? (which would make switching favorable) or 0.5 * E? (which would favor sticking with your original choice). The challenge lies in determining which scenario applies, as we must rely on probabilities.
Define the amount in the unselected envelope as E?. The probabilities are:
- P(E? = 2E?) for the first situation,
- P(E? = 0.5E?) for the second situation.
A simplistic assumption might lead us to conclude that both probabilities are equal: P(E? = 2E?) = P(E? = 0.5E?) = 0.5. In the first scenario, switching yields an additional E?, while in the second, switching results in a loss of 0.5E?. This results in an expected value calculation suggesting that switching increases your potential earnings by 0.25E?—a seemingly beneficial outcome.
However, this reasoning leads to a paradox. If switching is advantageous regardless of the amount E?, it implies that switching back would also be beneficial, creating a contradiction. Hence, the assumption that the probabilities are equal must be incorrect.
Section 1.2: The Role of E?
The truth is that the probabilities are influenced by the value of E?. For higher amounts, E? is more likely to be the larger sum, indicating P(E? = 0.5E?) > P(E? = 2E?). Conversely, for lower amounts, P(E? = 2E?) > P(E? = 0.5E?). This relationship can be exploited.
Now, a common question arises: how do we define "high" and "low" values for E?? Instead of drawing a strict line, we can choose any reference value, c, before examining the envelopes. The strategy is simple:
- If E? < c, switch envelopes.
- If E? > c, stick with your choice.
This approach significantly increases your chances of selecting the envelope with the larger amount.
The first video, "The Two Envelope Problem - a Mystifying Probability Paradox," delves into the intricacies of the Two Envelopes Problem, providing insight into the paradox and its implications.
Subsection 1.2.1: An Example with Specific Values
To illustrate this strategy, let’s consider integer amounts up to $10:
- $1 — $2
- $2 — $4
- $3 — $6
- $4 — $8
- $5 — $10
Assuming we set c = $4 and reveal an amount less than c, we can analyze the scenarios. The probability of finding E? less than c is more likely if it represents the smaller amount, leading to a situation where P(E? = 2E?) = 2/3, thus increasing the likelihood of switching successfully.
Switching strategies can be adapted for any chosen value of c, reinforcing the effectiveness of this method.
Chapter 2: Conclusion
To wrap up, this strategy allows participants to enhance their likelihood of selecting the larger envelope, surpassing a random guess of 50%.
The second video, "Solve The Two Envelopes Fallacy," explores common misconceptions and clarifies the logic behind the Two Envelopes Problem, offering viewers a deeper understanding of this intriguing paradox.
As always, thank you for engaging with this content!
References
McDonnell, M. D., & Abbott, D. (2009). Randomized switching in the two-envelope problem. Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, 465(2111), 3309–3322.
For those interested in supporting Street Science, consider contributing on Patreon.